Chapter 21, Northeast
In the Northeast, extreme weather events and other climate-driven changes are shaping mitigation and adaptation efforts, such as coastal wetland restoration and changes in fishing behavior. Many climate impacts in the region have disproportionate impacts on low-income communities and communities of color. Cities and states are implementing climate action plans with innovative approaches that embrace inclusive and equitable processes.
- From NCA5 ch. 21
This page is in draft form and is currently being reviewed by project partners. For more information about the creation and review process, please see the landing page for the NCA5 Educator's Guide.
Jump to:
- Information on using this guide
- Educational resources and guiding questions for this region
- CLEAN curated pathways to action for the region
- NCA5 non-regional chapter connections
Key Messages for the Northeast:
National Climate Assessment Art X Climate selections
Managed Retreat, Nathan Kensinger
Provenance: From Fifth National Climate Assessment 2023 (public .gov website)
Reuse: If you wish to use this item outside this site in ways that exceed fair use (see http://fairuse.stanford.edu/) you must seek permission from its creator.
Artist's statement: Over the past decade, I have documented the first "managed retreat" from climate change and sea level rise in New York City, photographing and filming as three neighborhoods have been demolished and returned to nature. This body of work explores the sacrifices that are being made, as communities face the reality of increased flooding, erosion, and storm surges caused by climate change and sea level rise.
Concrete Jungle, Jessica Beshears
Provenance: From the Fifth National Climate Assessment 2023 (public .gov website)
Reuse: If you wish to use this item outside this site in ways that exceed fair use (see http://fairuse.stanford.edu/) you must seek permission from its creator.
Artist's statement: Battling climate change will require a radically imaginative perspective on the world around us. What would it look like to create fully biophilic additions to buildings that already exist? How many jobs could be created through the planning and upkeep of a green city? How would gardens on every balcony and rooftop benefit people in food deserts? I used photos of common house plants tucked into an image of 30th Street and 5th Avenue in New York City for a fantastical view of a concrete jungle.
Educational resources and guiding questions aligned with the regional Key Messages:
Each Key Message features three guiding questions to help educators navigate these topics with students. Each guiding question includes example lessons and supporting videos. The lessons were taken from the Climate Literacy and Energy Awareness Network (CLEAN) educational resources database. The videos were selected from reputable sources to support the lessons.
Northeastern states and cities have adopted a range of plans, programs, and policies in response to extreme weather, many of which include nature-based strategies.
Provenance: Figure from The Fifth National Climate Assessment 2023 (public .gov website)
Reuse: If you wish to use this item outside this site in ways that exceed fair use (see http://fairuse.stanford.edu/) you must seek permission from its creator.
The Northeast continues to be confronted with extreme weather, most notably extreme precipitation—which has caused problematic flooding across the region—and heatwaves. In response, climate adaptation and mitigation efforts, including nature-based solutions, have increased across the region, with a focus on emissions reductions, carbon sequestration, and resilience building. Find out more about this key messagehere.
Guiding question one: How might extreme weather change life for people living in the Northeast?
Example Lesson
Extreme Event Game
LabX, The National Academy of Sciences
https://cleanet.org/resources/58725.html
Description: The Extreme Events Game is an in-person role-playing game that allows participants the experience of building community reliance in the face of disaster. Players work together to make decisions and solve problems during a fast-paced disaster simulation.
Instructional Time: 60 minutes
Grade Level: Sixth and up
Supporting Video
How Will Climate Change Continue to Affect Us?: Crash Course Climate & Energy #8
Crash Course
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eVUuwHGLIYo&list=PL8dPuuaLjXtMx8ZIQV9NduU_HFjDwykuj&index=9
Description: Our warming planet isn't just a threat to future generations; it's a threat to us right now. If we don't mitigate it, the continued rise in global temperature will have ripple effects throughout ecosystems and communities. In this episode of Crash Course Climate and Energy, we'll look at how climate change has already affected our planet, and what the future might hold.
Video Length: 14:21 minutes
Guiding question two: How do land use choices lead to more extreme weather event impacts in urban areas? How can land be developed to prevent/reduce extreme weather event impacts?
Example Lesson
Major Storms and Community Resilience
Lisa Doner, Lorraine Motola, Patricia Stapleton, Science Education Research Center at Carleton College
https://cleanet.org/resources/57226.html
Description: This is Unit 1 of a larger module and centers on the fundamental concepts of major storms and community resilience. In this unit, students acquire a vocabulary related to storm systems and risk, engage in practical exercises on event probability and frequency, and complete written activities and oral presentations that reinforce these concepts, using two case studies as examples.
Instructional Time: Two or three 90-minute class periods
Grade Level: Upper-level high school and undergraduate
Supporting Videos
What Makes Cities So Hot?
University Corporation for Atmospheric Research (UCAR) Center for Science Education with FableVision Studios, UCAR SkySci for Kids
https://cleanet.org/resources/59198.html
Description: This short video introduces the concept of the urban heat island effect.
Video Length: 44 seconds
I Live in the Eastern US – Does Climate Change Matter to Me? | Global Weirding Katharine Hayhoe, Global Weirding Series
https://cleanet.org/resources/56891.html
Description: This video discusses impacts that the Eastern US is experiencing due to climate change. It describes the seasonal shifts that may affect tourism in New England, extreme heat in the Southeast, how rising sea level affects coastal areas, changes in hurricane intensity, the spread of invasive species and disease, as well as other topics.
Video Length: 9:23 minutes
Guiding question three: What are some impacts on agriculture and locally available foods due to extreme weather impacts?
Example Lesson
The Effects of Climate Change on Agricultural Systems
Asombro Institute for Science Education
https://cleanet.org/resources/58896.html
Description: This set of five activities focuses on how climate change can affect agriculture, including crop production and ranching. The activities in this guide are appropriate for both formal and informal settings and all student handouts, instructor guides, and supporting files are included. The curriculum is designed for five days of activities that build on one another, but can also be used individually.
Instructional Time: This series of 5 learning activities each takes two 45-minute class periods
Grade Level: Ninth and up
Supporting Videos
U.S. Fisheries Face Climate Change
NOAA Fisheries
https://www.fisheries.noaa.gov/video/us-fisheries-face-climate-challenges
Description: Fisheries contribute more than $240 billion in economic activity in the United States every year. They support 1.7 million jobs and robust coastal economies while providing 9.3 billion pounds of seafood for consumers. But these fisheries are at risk due to climate change. Rising temperatures have shifted weather patterns, ocean currents, and even where fish live. They also affect the communities that rely on these fish for their livelihoods.
Video Length: 4:52 minutes
The ocean and coastal habitats in the Northeast are experiencing changes that are unprecedented in recorded history, including ocean warming, marine heatwaves, sea level rise, and ocean acidification. Changing ocean conditions are causing significant shifts in the distribution, productivity, and seasonal timing of life-cycle events of living marine resources in the Northeast. These impacts have spurred adaptation efforts such as coastal wetland restoration and changes in fishing behavior. Find out more about this key message here.
Guiding question one: How might changing ocean conditions affect fish and sea life communities in the marine ecosystems closest to you? How will that impact the regional economy?
Example Lesson
Carbonated Communities Lesson
Lacey Moore, Shape of Life, Sea Studios Foundation
https://cleanet.org/resources/57222.html
Description: This series of two lessons uses cutting-edge scientific research on the effects of climate change on communities in the intertidal. Through a combination of a dynamic presentation and several videos, students are introduced to the effects of climate change on the ocean (ocean acidification and temperature increase) and what is known about how ocean organisms are affected. Then students read and interpret graphs and construct a scientific explanation based on data from this research.
Instructional Time: Two 60-minute class periods.
Grade Level: Sixth and up
Supporting Videos
Acid Oceans
American Museum of Natural History (AMNH)
https://cleanet.org/resources/42796.html
Description: This video follows biologist Gretchen Hofmann as she studies the effects of ocean acidification on sea urchin larvae.
Video Length: 6:38 minutes
The Effects of Ocean Acidification on Pteropod Shells
NOAA's Pacific Marine Environmental Laboratory (PMEL)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6H_VDhXiFk4
Description: This video shows the difference in swimming behavior and shell structure in a shelled organism (Pteropod) developing in seawater with low surface CO2 and one developing in seawater with elevated CO2 conditions.
Video Length: 0:29 minutes
Guiding question two: What is needed for plant, animal, and human populations to adapt to climate change in the Northeast?
Example Lesson
Rising Tides: Protect Your Home from the Waves
Kate Carter, National Center for Science Education
https://cleanet.org/resources/58410.html
Description: Warming oceans and melting landlocked ice caused by global climate change may result in rising sea levels. This rise in sea level combined with increased intensity and frequency of storms will produce storm surges that flood subways, highways, homes, and more. In this activity, students design and test adaptations to prepare for flooding caused by sea level rise.
Instructional Time: 45-90 minutes, additional materials required
Grade Level: Kindergarten and up
Supporting Videos
Adapting to a changing climate
United Nations Climate Change Secretariat on behalf of the UNFCCC's Adaptation Committee
https://cleanet.org/resources/51293.html
Description: This 20-minute video, produced by the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change, describes adaptation strategies undertaken by several groups and nations in response to rising sea levels and other aspects of climate change.
Video Length: 19:34, but could be stopped at 15:30
Adaptation to Sea Level Rise
UN Environment Programme
https://www.unep.org/news-and-stories/video/adaptation-sea-level-rise
Description: Sea levels are rising at an increasing rate, threatening coastal communities with floods and storm surges. At the same time, ecosystem health is being weakened, leaving shorelines less able to protect communities from impacts. This video illustrates how coastal communities can restore natural resilience and adapt to sea level rise.
Video Length: 3:18 minutes
Guiding question three: What are some of the projected impacts for sea level rise? How can communities prepare for these potential impacts?
Example Lesson
Exploring Local Hazard Mitigation Plans
Cooperative Institute for Research in Environmental Sciences (CIRES) Outreach & Education
https://cires.colorado.edu/outreach/resources/lesson/exploring-local-hazard-mitigation-plans
Description: In order to be eligible for pre- and post-disaster grants from the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), each county must undergo a hazard mitigation planning process every five years. The purpose of the planning process is to reduce the impact of natural hazards to people, property, and infrastructure. In this lesson, students will explore their county Hazard Mitigation Plan to gain understanding about the hazards in their area (flooding, wildfire, or drought), including historic hazards, probability of future occurrences of the hazard, and vulnerability of the area to the hazard.
Instructional Time: 50 minutes
Grade Level: Sixth through twelfth
Notes: Lesson developed for Colorado, but can be easily adapted to any state
Supporting Video
Climate Change at the Doorstep
PBS
http://www.pbs.org/video/need-to-know-climate-change-at-the-doorstep-1/
Description: This PBS video focuses on sea level rise in Norfolk, Virginia and how the residents are managing the logistical, financial and political implications. Science journalists who have been studying Norfolk's rising sea level problems are interviewed, as well as local residents who are being impacted.
Video Length: 11:35 minutes
Average summer temperatures are generally higher in historically redlined neighborhoods in the Bronx, New York.
Provenance: From the Fifth National Climate Assessment 2023 (public .gov website)
Reuse: If you wish to use this item outside this site in ways that exceed fair use (see http://fairuse.stanford.edu/) you must seek permission from its creator.
Extreme heat, storms, flooding, and other climate-related hazards are causing disproportionate impacts among certain communities in the Northeast, notably including racial and ethnic minorities, people of lower socioeconomic status, and older adults. These communities tend to have less access to healthcare, social services, and financial resources and to face higher burdens related to environmental pollution and preexisting health conditions. Social equity objectives are prominent in many local-level adaptation initiatives, but the amount of progress toward equitable outcomes remains uneven. Find out more about this key message here.
Guiding question one: Why does climate change have a disproportionate impact on different communities?
Example Lesson
Understanding the impact of climate change on people with disabilities
PBS
https://www.pbs.org/newshour/classroom/lesson-plans/2024/01/lesson-plan-understanding-the-impact-of-climate-change-on-people-with-disabilities
Description: There's a good chance many people, adults included, may not be aware of the significant challenges facing people with disabilities during serious climate events, like hurricanes or snowstorms.
After watching the news segment, "How climate change risks impact people with disabilities," from PBS NewsHour's Disability Reframed series, students will work in small groups to study the problem and brainstorm solutions before sharing their insights with the class.
Instructional Time: 50 minutes
Grade Level: Sixth
EJScreen: Environmental Justice Screening and Mapping Tool
United States Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA)
https://cleanet.org/resources/53993.html
Description: This interactive mapping tool provides a dataset and approach for combining environmental and demographic socioeconomic indicators. EJScreen indicators are publicly-available data and this tool provides a method for viewing this information and combining environmental and demographic indicators into environmental justice indices. Use EJScreen with students to explore your local area.
Instructional Time: 20-60 Minutes
Grade Level: Sixth
Supporting Video
Are Natural Disasters Actually Natural? (Climate Justice): Crash Course Climate & Energy #9
Crash Course
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7ODrQW0vSmA&list=PL8dPuuaLjXtMx8ZIQV9NduU_HFjDwykuj&index=10
Description: Climate change has no bias, but our societies and systems do. And although it's a danger to all of us, a changing climate affects some groups disproportionately, raising issues of justice and equity. In this episode of Crash Course Climate and Energy, we'll take a look at the ways injustice within societal structures causes climate change to affect some more than others and discuss some of the work that environmental justice advocates are doing in response.
Video Length: 14:43 minutes
Guiding question two: How might extreme heat, flooding, storms, and other hazards alter ways of life for indigenous populations? What are the challenges with using relocation and land acquisition as adaptation strategies for Indigenous lands?
Example Lesson
'Don't Take Our Voices Away' A role play on the Indigenous Peoples' Global Summit on Climate Change
Julie Treick O'Neill, Tim Swinehart, Zinn Education Project
https://cleanet.org/resources/58855.html
Description: This resource has students role-play an Indigenous climate summit. It includes handouts about each Indigenous group and their concerns about climate change.
Instructional Time: Three 45-minute class periods
Grade Level: Sixth and up
Supporting Video
Through Tribal Eyes: Change on the Menominee Nation
United States Climate Resilience Toolkit
https://cleanet.org/resources/58958.html
Description: In this video, members of the Menominee nation discuss their experiences with climate change.
Video Length: 15:02 minutes
Guiding question three: Why is social equity important for managing climate-related hazards?
Example Lesson
Tackling Climate Change through Environmental Justice Middle School
EcoRise
https://cleanet.org/resources/59230.html
Description: This multi-lesson set is focused on environmental justice and social science. It asks students to consider inequality and justice in the context of their own lives and the environment through a series of both hands-on and research-focused activities.
Instructional Time: Three 60-minute class periods.
Grade Level: Elementary through high school resources available
Supporting Video
Rebuild by Design at Department of Design
CocreateSANL
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ssglSQcHkHA
Description: This video is about the Rebuild by Design competition offered to address the structural and social vulnerabilities exposed by Superstorm Sandy.
Video Length: 7:02 minutes
In recent years, there have been substantial advances in the magnitude and scope of climate action across all jurisdictional scales. Almost every state in the region has conducted or updated a climate impact assessment, developed a comprehensive climate action plan, and enacted climate-related laws since 2018. Innovative approaches to transparent, inclusive, and equitable processes around climate action are being embraced by Tribes, municipalities, and states. Although ambitious emissions reduction targets have been put forward, meeting these goals is expected to be challenging. Find out more about this key message here.
Guiding question one: What action plans are related to where you live? How ambitious are those plans?
Example Lesson
Almost every state in the Northeast United States has conducted or updated a climate impact assessment, developed a comprehensive climate action plan, and enacted climate-related laws since 2018. Statewide climate action plans are important for actively addressing the impacts caused by climate change.
Instructions: Read through the Key Message 4 section of the Fifth National Climate Assessment (NCA5), and answer the reading questions as you go. Hover over underlined words and terms in the Climate Assessment to learn more about them. Explore table 21.1. Note impact assessments, climate action plans, and climate-related laws for your state.
Reading Questions:
What is a climate impact assessment?
How might a climate impact assessment inform policy in your state?
Has your state performed an impact assessment? If so, what is the name of your state's impact assessment?
Does your state have a Climate action plan? If so, when was your state's action plan created (you may have to navigate to the action plan to find this answer)?
Conclude by discussing questions in small groups or as a class.
Instructional Time: 30-60 minutes
Grade Level: Ninth and up
Supporting Videos
This Maine town is being used to help create a statewide climate action plan
News Center Maine
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d2kZR_2EZr8
Description: This video examines how individuals in Maine are working to create a statewide climate action plan.
Video Length: 2:44 minutes, video should be started at 0:35
Vt. Climate Council adopts Climate Action Plan
WCAX, Vermont
https://www.wcax.com/video/2021/12/02/vt-climate-council-adopts-climate-action-plan/
Description: This video discusses Vermont's climate action plan created in 2021.
Video Length: 3:01 minutes
Guiding question two: What is needed to create a successful climate action plan in your region? What challenges may arise when creating a plan?
Example Lesson
Climate Action Simulation
Climate Interactive
https://cleanet.org/resources/58166.html
Description: This interactive role-playing simulation is conducted as a simulated emergency climate summit organized by the United Nations that convenes global stakeholders to establish a concrete plan that limits warming to Paris Agreement goals. This game is a fun format for large groups to explore climate change solutions and see what it would really take to address this global challenge.
Instructional Time: Two to four 60-minute class periods
Grades: Nine and up
Supporting Videos
What's Happening with the United Kingdom's Climate Policy
Center for Strategic & International Studies
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LdEVCraqxH0
Description: The UK has long positioned itself as a global leader on climate change. However, recent changes by Prime Minister Rishi Sunak's government have raised concerns among some Britons and environmentalists that the country will fall short of its promises. Joseph Majkut, Director of the CSIS Energy Security and Climate Change Program and Quill Robinson, Senior Program Manager and Associate Fellow, discuss the implications of these changes and how the UK can still demonstrate leadership and meet its climate commitments.
Video Length: 3:35 minutes
The $52.6 billion plan to save the NYC region from climate change
CNBC
https://www.cnbc.com/video/2023/03/04/the-52point6-billion-plan-to-save-the-nyc-region-from-climate-change.html
Description: The New York and New Jersey Harbor and Tributaries Study, also known as the HATS study, looks at how to protect the NYC area from another Hurricane Sandy. The Army Corps of Engineers is recommending a $52.6 billion plan to protect the region from climate change including seawalls, levees, and elevated promenades. Watch the video to find out more about what the plan entails and why the price tag is so high.
Video Length: 13:46 minutes
Guiding question three: How can your class or school participate in one of the climate action plans that applies to your community?
Example Lessons
Local K-12 Climate Action Plan: Key Questions To Get Started
Aspen Institute
https://www.thisisplaneted.org/img/K12-ClimateActionPlan-Guide-Screen-FINAL.pdf
Description: Teachers can adapt this guide into a worksheet for students to research climate action plans. This guide can prompt students to learn about sustainability and climate efforts in their school district and can facilitate students thinking about what a school climate action plan could include.
Grade Level: Kindergarten and up
Instructional Time: 50 minutes
Project Resilience: Resilience in Action
UCAR Center for Science Education
https://cleanet.org/resources/59184.html
Description: In this activity, students explore resilience toolkits to better understand their value. Students then draw upon these toolkits to design a resilience plan for their school campus as the culminating task of the larger Project Resilience.
Instructional Time: Five 50-60 minute class periods
Grade Level: Sixth and up
Supporting Videos
What are Climate Action Plans
University of Bristol
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=88RNyhCCkMA
Description: Climate Action Plans (CAPs) set out the activities an organization will undertake to reduce its carbon emissions in response to the climate and ecological emergency. At the University of Bristol, each School and Department is responsible for developing and delivering its CAP in relation to the carbon reduction opportunities in its area of the University. In this film, Climate Action Plan coordinators from around the University discuss why tailored plans are needed and the progress that's being made across campus.
Video Length: 1:48 minutes
A lighthouse in Maine photographed by Frank Winkler.
Provenance: Image by Frank Winkler from Pixabay
Reuse: This item is offered under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/ You may reuse this item for non-commercial purposes as long as you provide attribution and offer any derivative works under a similar license.
Options for financing mitigation and adaptation efforts have expanded in recent years, providing households, communities, and businesses with more options for responding to climate change. Flood insurance allows individuals and communities to recover following extreme flooding events, but many at-risk homeowners lack adequate coverage. Although the public sector remains the primary source of funding for adaptation, private capital has started to invest in a variety of mitigation and adaptation projects, including services for monitoring climate risks and community-based catastrophe insurance. Find out more about this key message here.
Guiding question one: How should we decide who pays for climate action?
Example Lesson
Greenhouse Emissions Reduction Role-Play Exercise
K.M. Theissen, University of St. Thomas, Pedagogy in Action Collection from SERC
https://cleanet.org/resources/42716.html
Description: In this role-play activity, students take the roles of various important players in the climate change policy negotiation including politicians, scientists, environmentalists, and industry representatives. Working in these roles, students must take a position, debate with others, and then vote on legislation designed to reduce greenhouse gas emissions in the United States. Can be used in a variety of courses including writing and rhetoric, and social sciences.
Instructional Time:photovoltaicsTwo 120-minute class periods.
Grade Level: Ninth and up
Supporting Videos
The Social Cost of Carbon
Climate Now
https://cleanet.org/resources/58909.html
Description: With the help of two climate experts, this video discusses how the social cost of carbon is calculated, how it should (perhaps) be calculated, and why the effort to quantify this value is necessary despite its imperfections.
Video Length: 8:59 minutes
Changing Planet: Rising Sea Level
NBC Learn, Windows to the Universe
https://cleanet.org/resources/42953.html
Description: This video discusses the social and economic impacts (worldwide and in the US) of sea level rise caused by global warming.
Video Length: 6:21 minutes
Guiding question two: How are climate change and flood insurance connected in the Northeast?
Example Lesson
HEART Force Flood Response Game
Cooperative Institute for Research in Environmental Sciences, University of Colorado Boulder
https://cleanet.org/resources/58190.html
Description: In this interactive game, students solve the challenges that their community faces during the course of an extreme flooding event by using available individual and community resources. Students work in three zone response teams to determine the responses they will take in each round as the flood situation evolves.
Instructional Time: 60 minutes
Grade Level: Sixth and up
Supporting Video
Climate Consequences: Flood insurance about to change
CNBC
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=002iztgqPe8
Description: CNBC's Diana Olick reports on FEMA's plan to overhaul flood insurance and what impact that's likely to have on homeowners.
Video Length: 3:21 minutes
Pathways to action for the Northeast*
*These selections were curated by CLEAN
The following actions and case studies highlight ideas for climate change adaptation and mitigation at multiple scales and are meant to support and inspire students and educators to take steps that address the challenges outlined in this chapter.
Action 1: Increase The Use Of Distributed Solar
Rooftop solar panels and solar photovoltaics offer hyper-local, clean electricity generation, whether grid-connected or part of a stand-alone battery system. For more information, see Drawdown Distributed Solar Solution: https://drawdown.org/solutions/distributed-solar-photovoltaics
Regional Case Study: Bob and Carmen Garver, co-owners of Wicked Joe, LLC, a coffee roasting company in Topsham, Maine, incorporated solar energy into their new facility.
https://toolkit.climate.gov/case-studies/wicked-joe-coffee-goes-solar
Classroom-level action: Assess if solar would be a good option for your school.
Description: Research the benefits of solar and the solar compatibility of your school. Determine if solar energy is a good option for your school. If it is, create a plan for implementation.
Supporting Resources:
Solutions Journalism Network, Rooftop Solar and Microgrids
https://solutionsu.solutionsjournalism.org/collections/5fp7unzzhl
Drawdown EcoChallenge Distributed Solar Actions
https://drawdown.ecochallenge.org/challenges/electricity
Action 2: Find Ways To Address Flooding With Infrastructure
Action 3: Coastal Wetlands Restoration
Action 4: Improve Fisheries Management
Looking for more ideas for climate change actions? Explore the National Climate Assessment chapters on adaptation (chapter 31) and mitigation (chapter 32).
National Climate Assessment Northeast Chapter Connections:
The national climate assessment includes multiple chapters on climate change-specific topics. The chapters and key messages offer ways to further engage with the NCA and find out more information related to the region.
Disclaimer: The National Climate Assessment regional resources for educators is written, edited, and moderated by each regional team of contributors. Posts reflect the views of the regional team themselves and not necessarily Climate.gov, NOAA and USGCRP.