Chapter 25, Northern Great Plains
The Northern Great Plains is experiencing unprecedented climate-driven extremes, including severe drought, floods, and wildfires. These changes threaten economic sectors such as agriculture and recreation and affect the health, well-being, and livelihood of the region's residents. While adaptation efforts are underway, climate change creates complex tradeoffs and tests the resilience of the region's residents, especially rural, Indigenous, and low-income immigrant populations.
- From chapter 25
This page is in draft form and is currently being reviewed by project partners. For more information about the creation and review process, please see the landing page for the NCA5 Educator's Guide.
Jump to:
- Information on using this guide
- Educational resources and guiding questions for this region
- CLEAN curated pathways to action for the region
- NCA5 non-regional chapter connections
Key Messages for the Northern Great Plains:
National Climate Assessment Art X Climate selections
Grinnell Mt. Gould Quadtych, Diane Burko
Provenance: Kevin Olivas Ordonez, University of Colorado at Boulder
Reuse: This item is offered under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/ You may reuse this item for non-commercial purposes as long as you provide attribution and offer any derivative works under a similar license.
Artist's statement:This work portrays Grinnell Glacier in Glacier National Park, Montana in four time periods between 1920 and 2006, with the glacier losing mass in each painting. The piece considers the marks that humanity leaves on the landscape, reflecting the impact of industrial and colonial activity on those same landscapes. While these paintings deal with impending climate catastrophe, rather than lingering in dystopia they celebrate the sublimity of the landscape by honoring the intricate geological and political webs that shape the identity of a place.
Endangered West, Taelyn B.
Provenance: Kevin Olivas Ordonez, University of Colorado at Boulder
Reuse: This item is offered under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/ You may reuse this item for non-commercial purposes as long as you provide attribution and offer any derivative works under a similar license.
Artist's statement: My drawing depicts 11 endangered species and their different ecosystems found in the Western United States. The most difficult challenge was making this piece cohesive, even across different habitats that normally wouldn't be found together. I live in Boise, Idaho, and am surrounded by wild places that I consider part of my home. I want to ensure that these ecosystems are protected. I hope viewers come away with an appreciation for our Western wild places and the importance of biodiversity and healthy ecosystems threatened by climate change and habitat loss.
Educational resources and guiding questions aligned with the regional Key Messages:
Each Key Message features three guiding questions to help educators navigate these topics with students. Each guiding question includes example lessons and supporting videos. The lessons were taken from the Climate Literacy and Energy Awareness Network (CLEAN) educational resources database. The videos were selected from reputable sources to support the lessons.
Key Message One: Climate Change Is Compounding the Impacts of Extreme Events
The Northern Great Plains region is experiencing unprecedented extremes related to changes in climate, including severe droughts, increases in hail frequency and size, floods, and wildfire. Rising temperatures across the region are expected to lead to increased evapotranspiration, as well as greater variability in precipitation. Find out more about this key messagehere.
Guiding question one: How does increased variability in precipitation affect runoff in the Northern Great Plains?
Example Lesson
What is a watershed?
Izaak Walton League
https://cleanet.org/resources/58917.html
Description: In this activity, students build a model of a watershed to learn where water goes when it rains. Students then make predictions and draw what they observe.
Instructional Time: One 60-minute period
Grade Level: Third to fifth
Supporting Videos
Field Research on Glacial Change
Teachers' Domain
https://cleanet.org/resources/43456.html
Description: This video describes how field research -- in this case, making water measurements in rugged mountain locations -- helps us to understand the complex relationships among changing climate, populations, and water usage.
Video Length: 4:50 minutes
Guiding question two: What factors contribute to the increased risk of wildfires in the Northern Great Plains and how have wildfire patterns changed over time in response to climate shifts?
Example Lesson
Wildfire Risk and Impact
The Concord Consortium
https://cleanet.org/resources/58910.html
Description: This course is comprised of five modules. Each one clearly explains the concept using readings and videos. Students are presented with the current fire and climate data and then run simulations. Students read graphs based on the data they collect in their simulations and then answer comprehension questions and make predictions.
Instructional Time: Five 60-minute class periods
Grade Level: Middle/high school
Supporting Videos
Wildfires Out West
Climate Central
https://cleanet.org/resources/43818.html
Description: This video from ClimateCentral looks at the way climate conditions can affect vegetation in the West, and what influence this has on wildfires. Drought and rainfall can have very different wildfire outcomes, depending on vegetation type, extent, and location.
Video Length: 3:13 minutes
Supporting Resource
Wildfire Simulation
The Concord Consortium
https://cleanet.org/resources/58452.html
Description: This is a wildfire simulation with three different zones (plains, mountains, and foothills). The user can change variables to see what happens when they spark a fire.
Guiding question three: Which hazards (wildfire, flooding, drought, hail, etc.) are of greatest concern for your community, and what can be done to mitigate or adapt to those hazards?
Example Lesson
Extreme Event Game
LabX, The National Academy of Sciences
https://cleanet.org/resources/58725.html
Description: The Extreme Events Game is an in-person role-playing game that allows participants the experience of building community reliance in the face of disaster. Players work together to make decisions and solve problems during a fast-paced disaster simulation.
Instructional Time: 60 minutes
Grade Level: Sixth and up
Supporting Videos
Assessing Drought in the United States
Colorado Climate Center
https://cleanet.org/resources/56887.html
Description: This video animation describes drought and explains the different categories of drought used by the drought monitor. It discusses the effects of and contributions to drought, what the implications of the different drought levels are, and puts the drought maps into context to understand how the impacts vary geographically (e.g. drought in Nevada vs Kansas - one could affect tourism, the other agriculture). It also touches on how the development of maps/drought severity is determined and how it might vary geographically.
Video Length: 6:05 minutes
Key Message Two: Human and Ecological Health Face Rising Threats from Climate-Related Hazards
Invasive cool-season grasses are reducing biodiversity in the Northern Great Plains.
Provenance: Kevin Olivas Ordonez, University of Colorado at Boulder
Reuse: This item is offered under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/ You may reuse this item for non-commercial purposes as long as you provide attribution and offer any derivative works under a similar license.
Climate-related hazards, such as drought, wildfire, and flooding, are already harming the physical, mental, and spiritual health of Northern Great Plains region residents, as well as the ecology of the region. As the climate continues to change, it is expected to have increasing and cascading negative effects on human health and on the lands, waters, and species on which people depend. Find out more about this key messagehere.
Guiding question one: In the Northern Great Plains how are human and ecological health threatened by the compounding impacts of climate change?
Example Lesson
Student Exploration of the Impacts of Climate Change on Human Health in the United States
National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences
https://cleanet.org/resources/56883.html
Description: This module follows the 5E instructional model to promote student discovery and learning about the complex interactions between climate change, the environment, and human health. Students describe the impacts of changing climatic conditions on human health with emphasis on vulnerable populations and apply systems thinking to create a visual model of various health implications arising from climate change.
Instructional Time: two to three 45-minute class periods
Grade Level: Ninth and up
Supporting Videos
Precipitation Extremes and Community Health
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
https://cleanet.org/resources/57229.html
Description: This short video explains how climate change can lead to more extreme precipitation events and more frequent flooding. Information from the CDC has succinct information about the health downsides of extreme precipitation events, including mental health impacts.
Video Length: 1:14 minutes
I Live in the Midwest and Northern Great Plains - Does Climate Change Matter to Me?
Global Weirding Series
https://cleanet.org/resources/56905.html
Description: This video features Katharine Hayhoe presenting a lively discussion of impacts that the Midwestern US is experiencing due to climate change. It steps through evidence for how climate change is affecting agriculture, tourism, drought and flood, water cycles and freshwater availability, the spread of invasive species and disease, as well as other topics.
Video Length: 9:21 minutes
Guiding question two: What is Solastalgia and which groups are likely to be most prone to it in your community?
Example Lesson
Through Salmon Eyes
Washington Office of Superintendent of Public Instruction
https://cleanet.org/resources/59225.html
Description: This activity tells a story through the eyes of a salmon, as told by Indigenous tribes of the Northwest. It celebrates traditional knowledge and how humans can think about the natural world through the viewpoint of salmon.
Instructional Time: One 40-minute class period
Grade Level: Elementary school
Supporting Videos
How climate change affects your mental health | Britt Wray
TED
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-IlDkCEvsYw&t=57s
Description: Britt Wray explores how climate change is threatening our well-being - mental, social, and spiritual - and offers a starting point for what we can do about it.
Video Length: 7:31
Supporting Resource
Ground Students in Place-Based Learning
CLEAN
https://cleanet.org/clean/literacy/elementary/strategies/placebased.html
Description: Engage students in authentic learning, inquiry, and research within their local environments and communities.
Tribal Climate Tool
University of California MERCED Climate Impacts Group
https://cleanet.org/resources/58181.html
Description: This tribal climate tool provides maps, graphs and reports that summarize projected changes in climate for specific tribes in the Pacific Northwest and Great Basin.
Guiding question three: How are invasive species like Cheatgrass and Bluegrass impacting ecological health in your state?
Example Lesson
Invasive Species Lesson Plan
Prickly Pear Land Trust
https://pricklypearlt.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Invasive-Species-Lesson-Plan.pdf
Description: This lesson prompts students to learn about invasive species in their region. Students will learn how to define invasive species, what the role humans play in the spread and management of invasive species, and what invasive species are common in the Pacific Northwest and Great Basin region.
Instructional Time: two to three 40-50 minute class periods
Grade Level: Fourth to tenth grade
Supporting Videos
Identifying Invasive Annual Grasses in Montana
MSU Extension
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=if2wKRfdWYY
Description: This video covers field characteristics important for identifying four non-native annual grasses invasive in Montana: cheatgrass (Bromus tectorum), Japanese brome (Bromus japonicus), ventenata (Ventenata dubia), and medusahead (Taeniatherum caput-medusae).
Video Length: 6:12 minutes
Invasive Species 101 | National Geographic
National Geographic
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gYNAtw1c7hI&t=204s
Description: Invasive species cost the global economy over a trillion dollars each year. Find out how these non-native organisms are introduced into an ecosystem, how they impact local communities, and which measures can be taken to help prevent the introduction of invasive species.
Video Length: 3:31 minutes
Key Message Three: Resource and Land-Based Livelihoods Are at Risk
The Northern Great Plains region is heavily reliant on agriculture and resource-based economies, placing livelihoods at risk from the impacts of climate change and related policy. Agriculture and recreation will see some positive effects but primarily negative effects related to changing temperature and precipitation regimes. Energy-sector livelihoods will be affected as emissions-reductions policies drive shifts away from fossil fuel sources. Climate change is expected to test the adaptive resilience of the region's residents, in particular rural, Indigenous, and low-income immigrant populations. Find out more about this key message here.
Guiding question one: Why does climate change have a disproportionate impact on different communities?
Example Lesson
Food and Climate Change Curriculum
Alana Siegner
https://cleanet.org/resources/56870.html
Description: Comprehensive curriculum/unit to teach how food systems affect climate change. Strong use of real data is embedded throughout. Full lessons, mini-lessons, and short videos are presented.
Instructional Time: The series of 6 lessons takes 45 minutes each.
Grade Level: Sixth through twelfth
Supporting Video
Conservation for the Future: Regenerative Agriculture with the Hawks Family, Galata, MT
Montana USDA
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t7B1fty_hPQ
Description: Cory and Belinda Hawks are progressive young producers deeply committed to regenerative agriculture, starting with their dedication to building soil health. They are using many practices on both their grazing and croplands to achieve results that are improving their operation's resilience.
Video Length: 5:03 minutes
Guiding question two: How are the livelihoods of indigenous communities in your state likely to be impacted by climate change?
Example Lesson
Indigenous Peoples
U.S. Climate Resilience Toolkit
https://toolkit.climate.gov/regions/northern-great-plains/indigenous-peoples
Description: Tribal nations of the Northern Great Plains are at high risk from climate change impacts, which are already resulting in harmful effects on tribal economies, livelihoods, and sacred waters and plants. Collaboration across tribal, local, state, and federal entities is key to addressing tribal climate change impacts. Divide the class into 3-5 small groups and have each group focus on a key point. Once each group understands their key point, have each group present what they have learned to the class.
Instructional Time: One class period
Grade Level: Sixth through twelfth
Supporting Video
North Dakota Tribal Members Talk About Climate Change
WGBH, Teachers' Domain
https://cleanet.org/resources/43800.html
Description: In this short video segment Native Americans talk about climate change and how it impacts their lives as they experience unexpected changes in environmental conditions. They describe observed changes in seasonality, how these changes affect ecosystems and habitats, their respect for Mother Earth, and the participation of tribal colleges in climate change research projects.
Video Length: 2:15 minutes
Guiding question three: Which types of energy does your state use and produce? How is climate change likely to impact both energy consumption and production?
Example Lesson
Great Energy Debate
National Energy Education Development (NEED)
https://cleanet.org/resources/43021.html
Description: This is a debate-style learning activity in which student teams learn about energy sources and are then assigned to represent the different energy sources. Working cooperatively, students develop arguments on the pros and cons of their source over the others.
Instructional Time: Two to three 45 minute class periods
Grade Level: Sixth through twelfth
Supporting Video
Energy Sources
WGBH Educational Foundation, Teachers' Domain
https://cleanet.org/resources/40661.html
Description: This short video surveys the different current and potential sources of energy - both non-renewable and renewable. It provides some discussion of the pros and cons of the different sources and explains how they are used to produce energy that people can use.
Video Length: 6:09 minutes
Key Message Four: Climate Response Involves Navigating Complex Trade-Offs and Tensions
The Northern Great Plains region shows wide geographical variations in land use and social vulnerability.
Provenance: Kevin Olivas Ordonez, University of Colorado at Boulder
Reuse: This item is offered under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/ You may reuse this item for non-commercial purposes as long as you provide attribution and offer any derivative works under a similar license.
Climate change is creating new, and exacerbating existing, tensions and trade-offs between land use, water availability, ecosystem services, and other considerations in the region, leading to decisions that are expected to benefit some and set back others. Decision-makers are navigating a complicated landscape of shifting demographics, policy and regulatory tensions, and barriers to action. Changes in temperature and precipitation averages, extremes, and seasonality will alter the productivity of working lands, resulting in land-use shifts to alternative crops or conversion to grasslands. Shifts in energy demand, production, and policy will change land-use needs for energy infrastructure. Find out more about this key message here.
Guiding question one: What are the economic challenges and opportunities the Northern Great Plains may experience from reducing their reliance on fossil fuels?
Example Lesson
Food and Climate Change Curriculum
Alana Siegner
https://cleanet.org/resources/56870.html
Description: Comprehensive curriculum/unit to teach how food systems affect climate change. Strong use of real data is embedded throughout. Full lessons, mini-lessons, and short videos are presented.
Instructional Time: The series of 6 lessons takes 45 minutes each.
Grade Level: Sixth through twelfth
Supporting Videos
Renewable Energy 101
National Geographic
https://cleanet.org/resources/58926.html
Description: This is a National Geographic video that defines renewable energy and discusses the benefits and drawbacks of different examples.
Video Length: 3:16 minutes
Guiding question two: What cultural, structural, and institutional barriers may make climate change adaptation and mitigation efforts more difficult in the Northern Great Plains region?
Example Lesson
Tackling Climate Change through Student Innovation: Decarbonizing the Electric Grid
EcoRise
https://cleanet.org/resources/59228.html
Description: This two-part resource from GreenVision Energy broadly introduces students to vocabulary like renewable energy, load and demand response, carbon capture and sequestration, and environmental justice. Students will learn about the challenges of integrating renewable energy into the current energy grid system and navigating energy equity concepts caused by climate change through podcasts, worksheets, and discussion questions.
Instructional Time: Two 50 minute class periods
Grade Level: Ninth through twelfth
Supporting Videos
A New Climate Vision*
TED Explores
https://watch.montanapbs.org/video/ted-explores-a-new-climate-vision-xwnj49/
Description: The documentary looks at the encouraging growth of technologies that can slow or reverse climate change. While the effects of climate change are growing, so are the world's attempts to reverse them. Hosted by Manoush Zomorodi of the TED Radio Hour, this special from the team behind TED Talks examines the rapid technological revolution underway and the real possibility of a better future for all.
Video Length: 56:46 minutes
*Consider watching from 3:04-12:55 for an overview on the basics of fossil fuels and how some industries are experiencing change in their adaptation and mitigation efforts
Guiding question three: Which land-use conversion strategies are possible in and around your community? What trade-offs could be necessary to enable these conversions?
Example Lessons
Sustainable Grazing
California Academy of Sciences
https://www.calacademy.org/educators/lesson-plans/sustainable-grazing
Description: Humans need food and water to survive. In this activity, students will learn what it takes to develop, grow and consume some of the foods and water we need.
Instructional Time: 60 minutes
Grade Level: Six through twelfth
Supporting Videos
Energy 101: Wind Turbines
U.S. Department of Energy/Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy
https://cleanet.org/resources/42803.html
Description: This video provides a simple introduction to wind turbines and how they generate electricity.
Video Length: 2:16 minutes
Key Message Five: Communities Are Building the Capacity to Adapt and Transform
Adaptation is underway in the Northern Great Plains to address the effects of climate change. Agricultural communities are shifting toward climate adaptation measures such as innovative soil practices, new drought-management tools, and water-use partnerships. Several Tribal Nations are leading efforts to incorporate Traditional Knowledge and governance into their adaptation plans. Resource managers are increasingly relying on tools such as scenario planning to improve the adaptive capacity of natural ecosystems. Find out more about this key message here.
Guiding question one: Who are the potential stakeholders from agriculture industries that are involved in climate adaptation plans in the Northern Great Plains region and what are their roles?
Example Lesson
Climate Action Simulation
Climate Interactive
https://cleanet.org/resources/58166.html
Description: This interactive role-playing simulation is conducted as a simulated emergency climate summit organized by the United Nations that convenes global stakeholders to establish a concrete plan that limits warming to Paris Agreement goals. This game is a fun format for large groups to explore climate change solutions and see what it would really take to address this global challenge.
Instructional Time: Two to four 60-minute class periods
Grade Level: Ninth and up
Supporting Videos
I Live in the Midwest and Northern Great Plains - Does Climate Change Matter to Me?
Katharine Hayhoe, Global Weirding Series
https://cleanet.org/resources/56905.html
Description: This video features Katharine Hayhoe presenting a lively discussion of impacts that the Midwestern US is experiencing due to climate change. It steps through evidence for how climate change is affecting agriculture, tourism, drought and flood, water cycles and freshwater availability, the spread of invasive species and disease, as well as other topics.
Video Length: 9:21 minutes
Guiding question two: Why is it important to include Indigenous communities and voices in the development of adaptation plans?
Example Lesson
'Don't Take Our Voices Away' A role play on the Indigenous Peoples' Global Summit on
Julie Treick O'Neill, Tim Swinehart, Zinn Education Project
https://cleanet.org/resources/58855.html
Description: This resource has students role-play an Indigenous climate summit. It includes handouts about each Indigenous group and their concerns about climate change.
Instructional Time: Three 45-minute class periods
Grade Level: Sixth and up
Supporting Video
How Indigenous Communities Are Fighting Climate Change
PGW Digital Studios
https://www.pbs.org/video/how-indigenous-communities-are-fighting-climate-change-yh3qnz/
Description: Learn more about #LandBack, an Indigenous-led environmental, cultural, and political movement that seeks to place Indigenous land back in Indigenous hands.
Video Length: 10:10 minutes
Guiding question three: What climate adaptation plans have been created in your community and state? How has traditional ecological knowledge influenced those plans?
Example Lesson
Your Place in Focus | Adaptation
Shari Carswell, Public Broadcasting Service
https://cleanet.org/resources/58955.html
Description: This lesson guides students to connect the PBS Adaptation video series on climate adaptation to their own community. Students describe their community, identify climate impacts faced by their community, research how their community is adapting to those impacts, and then create a digital story about what they found.
Instructional Time: Two 50-minute class periods
Grade Level: Sixth through twelfth
Supporting Video
Indigenous Communities Are on the Front Lines of Climate Change
PBS
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xlGnve1cjOY
Description: As the world figures out how to live with a rapidly changing climate, traditional knowledge from indigenous cultures could help us understand just how things are transforming.
Video Length: 6:11 minutes
Supporting Resources
45 states, large metro areas submit climate action plans under President Biden's Inflation Reduction Act
United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)
https://www.epa.gov/newsreleases/45-states-large-metro-areas-submit-climate-action-plans-under-president-bidens
Pathways to action for the Northern Great Plains*
*These selections were curated by CLEAN
The following actions and case studies highlight ideas for climate change adaptation and mitigation at multiple scales and are meant to support and inspire students and educators to take steps that address the challenges outlined in this chapter.
Action 1: Incorporating Indigenous peoples' knowledge
Action 2: Improve Cattle Farm Management
Action 3: Reduce Agriculture Impacts
Conservation agriculture uses cover crops, crop rotation, and minimal tilling to produce annual crops. It protects soil, avoids emissions, and sequesters carbon. For more information, see Drawdown Conservation Agriculture solution: https://drawdown.org/solutions/conservation-agriculture
Regional Case Study: Implementing no-till agriculture in Montana
https://storymaps.arcgis.com/stories/d8f366c63efe4a7f9cc8a4bed7a0db49
Classroom-level action: Explore local food options
Description: Research local producers in your areas. Learn about CSA options, local farmers markets, food co-ops, food rescue, local foraging groups, or gardening.
Supporting Resources:
Drawdown Ecochallenge support local food systems https://drawdown.ecochallenge.org/challenges/food-agriculture-and-land-use#:~:text=SUPPORT%20LOCAL%20FOOD%20SYSTEMS
National Sustainable Agriculture Coalition National Guide to Finding Local Food
https://sustainableagriculture.net/blog/national-guide-to-finding-local-food/
Action 4: Improve Water Efficiency
Drip and sprinkler irrigation, among other practices and technologies, make farm water use less energy/fuel intensive and conserve significant amounts of freshwater. For more information, see Drawdown Farm Irrigation Efficiency Solution: https://drawdown.org/solutions/farm-irrigation-efficiency
Regional Case Study: For irrigated crops, knowing when and how much water to apply has long been a matter of experience and guesswork. In a changing climate, new technology can reduce this uncertainty, enabling farmers to make every drop of water count.
https://toolkit.climate.gov/case-studies/precise-soil-climate-and-weather-data-help-dairy-optimize-water-use
Classroom-level action: Assess your school's water usage and brainstorm ways to reduce it
Description: Brainstorm the ways your school uses water, then think of ways that usage could be reduced.
Supporting Resources:
Water footprint calculator
https://www.watercalculator.org/wfc2/q/household/
EPA guide for reducing water in educational facilities
https://www.epa.gov/watersense/types-facilities#:~:text=best%20management%20practices.-,Educational%20Facilities,-Approximately%20six%20percent
Implement water-saving measures
https://19january2017snapshot.epa.gov/www3/region1/eco/drinkwater/water_conservation_schools.html#:~:text=To%20reduce%20water%20use%20in,reduce%20water%20use%20during%20showers
Looking for more ideas for climate change actions? Explore the National Climate Assessment chapters on adaptation (chapter 31) and mitigation (chapter 32).
National Climate Assessment Northern Great Plains Chapter Connections:
The national climate assessment includes multiple chapters on climate change-specific topics. The chapters and key messages offer ways to further engage with the NCA and find out more information related to the region.
Disclaimer: The National Climate Assessment regional resources for educators is written, edited, and moderated by each regional team of contributors. Posts reflect the views of the regional team themselves and not necessarily Climate.gov, NOAA and USGCRP.